Pre-Combine CB Rankings

Before I get into the CB rankings, I wanted to tell you that I have a sneaking suspicion that Fred Kirsch took his wife to Bass Pro Shop for lunch. The man’s a menace. He goes to Bass Pro for everything from chicken wings to the tube socks he wears with his sandals. He’s totally bonkos.

Now on to a position the Patriots need to bolster, regardless of whether or not they re-sign Asante Samuel this offseason.

Note: To be fair to our followers, I don’t like to voice opinions on players I haven’t seen play a lot. And as much college football as I’ve watched this year, I’m sorry to say that I haven’t seen Tennessee State play. Because of this, I haven’t formed an opinion on Dominique Rodgers-Cromartie yet. I saw him at the Senior Bowl and he certainly looks like a player but I’ll have to watch film on him before I can rank him and comment on him with a shred of intelligence.

1. Antoine Cason, Arizona - I’m going down with the ship on this one. I’ve watched Cason play since he was a freshman and the last three years, he hasn’t only been the best corner in the nation, he’s one of the best players at that position I’ve ever seen play college football. Now Mel Kiper is telling me Cason is going to be a second-day pick because he’s slow? I just can’t buy that. I believe the corner position is one of the most mis-evaluated (Just an FYI: I’m pretty sure I made this word up) areas this time of year for one simple reason: instincts. The best corners have great instincts. But right now scouts and fans will fall in love with guys who run 4.2 40’s, yet can’t recognize a pass route. A perfect example of what I’m trying to say is right here in New England. Ellis Hobbs is faster than Asante Samuel but he doesn’t have Samuels’ feel for the game. Touchdown Plaxico Burress. See my point?

I’m sorry for the long rant but I’m shocked where some of these “experts” have Cason ranked. He has tremendous instincts, is extremely smart and much like Samuel Cason has the ability to peel off his man and jump a receiver’s route. I keep hearing he’s slow but I’ve watched the guy pick off passes and return punts to the house while easily blowing past people. Cason is so slow that he participated on the University of Arizona’s track team. Cason started all 46 games in college, has great coverage skills (15 career interceptions), is a solid tackler and can return punts. Oh yeah, he also moved to safety last year for the good of the team when the Wildcats secondary was decimated by injuries. Other than that, Cason isn’t much of a prospect. In my opinion, Cason is not only the best corner in this year’s draft but one of the best defensive players overall. Now, please don’t go out and run a 5.2.

2. Mike Jenkins, South Florida - Jenkins is a great athlete with tremendous closing speed. He was a key member of a stingy South Florida defense last year when he recorded 42 tackles and three interceptions. Jenkins has experience playing both corner and safety but is better suited at corner because of his natural coverage abilities. Jenkins is a four-year starter who still offers a lot of upside. He’ll be in contention to be the first corner selected in this year’s draft, which means Jenkins could end up in New England.

3. Aqib Talib, Kansas - Right now I have Jenkins and Talib basically neck and neck for that No. 2 corner spot. Talib is a true ballhawk, as his 13 career interceptions will attest. Talib is probably the most athletically gifted corner in this draft and those skills even allowed him to play some offense in college. Talib excels in man-to-man coverage but he still needs some work playing zone. He was impressive for most of the season but one red flag is he didn’t have great games against Nebraska and Missouri - two of the best passing teams Kansas played last year. Still, Talib has the talent and physical skills to be a shutdown corner at the NFL level.

4. Reggie Smith, Oklahoma - Smith is one of the most versatile defensive backs in this year’s draft class with experience at corner and free safety. Like Cason, Smith isn’t the fastest corner in the world but he makes up for it with good instincts on the field. He’s one of those players that always seems to be around when there’s a fumble or tipped pass. Smith is returning from a toe injury that kept him out of the Fiesta Bowl but he’ll climb up draft boards if he runs well at the Combine.

5. Leodis McKelvin, Troy - I only saw McKelvin play a couple of times, so I need to watch a lot more tape of him before I move him up my draft board. I know McKelvin is the flavor of the month with the draft experts but I’ll be interested to see how he played in big games this past season. Troy played a tough schedule that included Florida, Georgia, Oklahoma State and Arkansas. I want to see how he matched up with the receivers from those schools. On the plus side, McKelvin is one of the best return men in this draft but on the negative side, he’s built like and reminds me a lot of Ellis Hobbs. I will have a much better read on McKelvin after the Combine and watching some more tape of him.

Overrated
McKelvin - There’s no way anyone is going to tell that at this point in the process, McKelvin is a top 10 pick and a better corner prospect than Cason, Jenkins and Talib. No way.

Underrated
Cason
- Don’t get me started again.

Sleeper
Chevis Jackson, LSU
- He’s not getting talked about much but Jackson is a smooth corner with good ball skills. Jackson isn’t flashy and he really doesn’t stand out in one particular area but he has the ability to be a dependable NFL corner and would represent great value as a mid-round pick.

11 Responses to “Pre-Combine CB Rankings”

  1. Kenny T Says:

    I have no idea who Cason is but after reading that fantastic rant I am now a fan and I hope we pick him. Sounds to me like if no one else thinks much of him he will slip and we can get him late in the draft rather then early, how great would it be to grab Talib in the 1st (I think Talib is the CB in the draft by far) and then grab Cason in the 2nd or 3rd. Do you think your boy Cason could slip that far?

  2. tomcasale Says:

    Kenny,
    If Cason runs well at the Combine, he’ll be a first-round pick because if you run a 4.3, then your college career matters but if you run a 4.5, it doesn’t for some reason. If not, he’ll probably be a second round selection. Kiper - who is a shadow of what he once was in my opinion - is nuts if he thinks Cason will be around on Day 2. He’ll have to have an awful performance at the Combine for that to happen. I have loved Kiper over the years and have always respected his opinion but he does so many extra things now like radio, I think it’s time for Tod McShay to take that job over.

  3. Fred Says:

    So what if I took my wife to Bass Pro for lunch. The wings are excellent. I’m thinking of making them required eating once a week for all PFW writers.

  4. Craig from Boxborough Says:

    I hope the so-called draft experts are right in the second day pick prediction! (Draft steal alert)

  5. Matt from Quincy Says:

    This is going to sound weird, but Cason is extremely bow-legged, and maybe I’m prejudiced, but bow-legged guys just don’t run real fast. Sorry Tom, but I think he’s going to be a safety (and a very good one) in the NFL.

  6. Chuck from Jamaica Says:

    Fred email me the menu from Bass, please. I’ve wanted to send lunch to your crew. They can’t pick the right team to win, so they deserve to eat what they get. Tell them it taste like crow.
    Chuck (temp) Spanish Town, Jamaica.

  7. John Smith Says:

    Tom, what do you think of Brandon Flowers? From what I’ve seen, he seemed to be a better fit at free safety, but what do I know?

  8. Mike M Says:

    Not quite sure how Flowers doesn’t crack the top 5. He may run a slow time, which coiuld push him down a bit, but he’s a first rounder.

  9. George Raab Says:

    Andy, where’s Brandon Fllowers? Mayock said after watching tape on him, that he’s a future Pro-Bowler.
    McKelvin has great feet, hips and instincts. He has stones for hands. If he could learn to catch the ball, watch out!
    Mike Jenkins, propbably the safest pick.
    Aqib Talib has it all, a little raw, but probably has the most upside.
    Is Stanton and Chevis Jackson the same type of players, highly instinctful but, considered slow 4.6, 4.7

  10. Mike M Says:

    For the record, USA today has Cason listed at #23 in it’s list of the 100 top draft prospects. So you’re not alone in your evaluation.

  11. tomcasale Says:

    Mike M,
    The reason why Flowers isn’t in my top 5 is because I don’t really like him. I follow Va Tech closely and I can tell you that I normally love the defensive players that come out from there. However, this year I think a lot of their prospects are overrated, led by Flowers, who is a third-round talent in my opinion.

Leave a Reply